Comments on: Extreme jobs and how many hours we work https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/ Writer, Author, Speaker Tue, 30 Mar 2021 00:59:21 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 By: Constance Murphy https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-203597 Tue, 30 Mar 2021 00:59:21 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-203597 Laura, I know this article is about tracking work hours, but I wish there were a way to report on the stress of jobs that may only require 40 hours per week, but employees have to work through lunch in order to stay on top of the work. Or in my case, I am required to eat lunch with my students at the school where I teach. (And yes, the union says it’s okay!)

]]>
By: Amanda https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-201044 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 23:00:37 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-201044 In reply to Amanda.

And by the way in case anyone doesn’t know residents actually are required to track their work hours now, every week, every day. So we know exactly how much we worked.

]]>
By: Amanda https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-201043 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 22:57:30 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-201043 In reply to Gillian.

I finished residency and fellowship last year and cannot imagine going back to working that much. Truly working 80 hours per week, or even 60 hours was so brutal. When I first started reading Laura’s work I was like, yep, most people have no idea what actually working 80 hours would feel like. Like @Annie I also hate being on call even as an attending just because I don’t like the feeling of being on the whole time, but fortunately I only do this a few times a year now.

]]>
By: Laura Vanderkam https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-201019 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 21:06:31 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-201019 In reply to Maggie.

@Maggie – this is a good question. My general sense is that if the outcomes of the job are being met, then the hours aren’t the most important factor. Now, if someone is doing the job in 2 hours a week, they’ll probably be bored enough that this justifies a talk with a supervisor. There is also a problem if a normal full-time job seems to be taking a lot longer than other employees are working. But within a 30-50 range we’re probably all OK.

]]>
By: Maggie https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-201009 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 20:42:25 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-201009 I am wondering how you judge the fact that many people do not work the 40 hours they are paid for. On one hand, I think many jobs are more about output than hours, on the other hand when I work only 30 hours a week, I feel guilty.

]]>
By: Ashley https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-201007 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 20:36:15 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-201007 What often gets overlooked in these conversations is the mental energy that work requires. I might be working 40-45 hours a week, but if I have a lot of start-and-stop tasks, or responsibilities that require immediate action/response/output, that feels a lot worse than 40-45 hours of steady work without highs and lows. I know when I can’t get into the groove workwise — usually because of factors outside my control — I do not have as much mental energy to enjoy the downtime. Or to even PLAN how I want to spend my downtime. I agree with your premise that time tracking can show useful patterns, but I maintain that not all hours are created equal.

]]>
By: Gillian https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-200995 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 19:59:31 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-200995 In reply to Annie.

@Annie I was going to say the same think. An every 4th night 24 hour call like I did in my residency days averages an 80 hour work week with some weeks feeling awful (on call from from 8 am Saturday to 11 am Sunday “Black weekend”) and some weeks aren’t so bad (Call from 8am Thursday to 10 am Friday then off Sat and Sunday “Golden weekend”). Talking about this still sends shivers up my spine, and I trained after work-hours rules were imposed for residents. Back in the old days residents could take 24 hour hour calls every two days and could easily rack up >100 hours per week of work.

Of course, most residents expect a better schedule after they complete their training. I haven’t slept in a hospital call room in almost 10 years and life is MUCH more balanced. I am not sure I would have gone into medicine if 80 hour work weeks continued beyond residency/fellowship.

]]>
By: Annie https://lauravanderkam.com/2021/03/extreme-jobs-and-how-many-hours-we-work/#comment-200952 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 17:50:21 +0000 https://lauravanderkam.com/?p=17966#comment-200952 I think you will find many people in medicine who still take call shifts (up to 24-30 hours) often feel like they work ‘all the time’ and/or really do have high tallies – a 24 hour day makes the hours add up fast, even if the rest of the week is reasonable. Do we really work 24 full hours without stopping – it depends on the day! Sometimes you can fit other things in. There is also the particular torture known as ‘home call’ – does talking on the phone with my patient while drowning out the screaming from the birthday party my kid is at count as work or kid time? So many counting dilemmas! But I think being ‘on call’ where you are often able to do other things, but still with one ear for the pager (or whatever way you define as being ‘on’) is one reason why I, at least, feel like I am working ‘all the time’ even when the hours may not show that.

]]>